Jump to content
THE BROWNS BOARD

Who is the most overrated player in the NFL?


jrb12711

Recommended Posts

Posted

my friend (a Bears fan) and I were having a good argument about players we thought were extremely overrated. I thought it'd be interesting to see who everyone thinks is THE most overrated player, and why

 

For me without a doubt it's Jay Cutler. Everyone considers the guy a top 10 QB, when honestly he hasn't shown anything to prove he should be considered in the top 20. He can make all the throws sure, but he makes awful, awful decisions and is extremely arrogant and cocky. Not to mention he literally hasn't been a winner since high school.

 

 

Remember, these are just opinions, so no need to get pissed at people. So, what do you guys think?

  • Replies 89
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Posted

Sanchez

Romo

Santana Moss

Matt Cassel

Bowe

 

JaMarcus Russel, Heyward Bey, but thats pretty obvious

 

Merriman

Gore

Carson Palmer

Ben I cant keep my hands to myself Roethlisberger

Cutler

Hester

Vince Young

 

and whoever said haynesworth is overrated clearly has not watched him play

Posted

Jay Kuntler or Tony Homo.........Its a toss up for me!

 

Had to use a K to get past the word police

Posted

Brett Favre - not saying he's not a great QB, I just think he gets way too much media attention. I'm sick of hearing about Favre's greatness even during games he has no connection to.

 

Braylon Edwards - Browns fans knew this already, but Jets fans got a taste this year.

 

Mark Sanchez - can't believe he was getting credit for taking the Jets to the AFCG, that was all the Defense/OL/RBs doing. He did good for a rookie though.

Posted
The entire Ratbird offense

 

did anyone really talk about their offense last year outside of Ray Rice? If anything I'd say ravens defense is way overrated. They are coasting on the reputation of their past teams.

Posted

Jay Culter followed by "Give me Oxygen" Rogers

Posted
Heinz Ward

 

Then that guy that Rapes chicks.

yet 4 Super Bowl Rings between the two of them... LOL, Yes you have a Clue !!! Not !

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...