BernietheKid Posted December 26, 2008 Report Share Posted December 26, 2008 Need a GM? Here's a short list of the best candidates By Pat Kirwan | NFL.com Senior Analyst Running an NFL franchise isn't easy. Can you evaluate personnel, manage a salary cap, negotiate contracts, select a head coach, handle the media, make tough decisions, cooperate with an owner, deal with the league office and, most importantly, carry out a vision for a winning franchise? If so, then you qualify for the job. There are only 32 such positions as general manager in the NFL, and there may not be 32 people capable of handling all the dimensions of the job. A number of owners will be looking for a front-office executive to steer the course over the next few years, and they are all looking at the same pool of talent. Marc Serota / Getty Images Bill Parcells has guided Miami to quite a turnaround in just one season. The first question that needs to be answered is this: What type of leader do you want? A guy with experience that comes in with a proven plan? A younger person with less experience but new and fresh ideas? Someone closer to the age of the owner who can relate to the boss? Someone who can recruit the best coach possible? A man who really knows the talent floating around the country in the draft and on the free-agent market? How about a guy from one of the smart, business-minded franchises that makes the owner more money while still providing a winning team? Getting the right person for the job is complex, but a number of teams will be looking to this list for the perfect fit. A look at recent front-office hirings will help categorize the candidates into four groups. Group 1 is comprised of experienced executives with a track record who are possibly looking for work, or the Rich McKay model, the former Atlanta Falcons GM. Group 2 is a relatively new concept where a proven coach now takes over the front office rather than coach the team, or the Bill Parcells model, for lack of a better term. Group 3 is the proven club executive that does not have total GM power. He can be lured if you hand him the keys to the kingdom, and as such this group will be labeled the Jerry Angelo model after the Chicago Bears GM. Group 4 is the young understudy who has paid his dues and is ready for the challenge. This group will be labeled the Thomas Dimitroff group after the Atlanta Falcons GM. Here are the candidates in alphabetical order: Group 1 (Rich McKay model) This group of candidates has done everything required of a GM; there is no learning curve. Show them where their office is and they are up and running. Charlie Casserly: Former GM of the Washington Redskins and Houston Texans, Casserly is now working on CBS' "NFL Today" show. James Harris: Just resigned front office executive of the New York Jets, Baltimore Ravens and Jacksonville Jaguars. Ron Hill: Former front-office executive for the Jacksonville Jaguars and Atlanta Falcons, Hill is presently assistant director of football operations for the NFL. Mike Lombardi: Former front office executive for the Cleveland Browns and Oakland Raiders, in addition to club experience with the San Francisco 49ers, Denver Broncos and Philadelphia Eagles. Carl Peterson: Just resigned as president of the Kansas City Chiefs after 20 years. He is well respected in NFL circles and may want to continue his career with another team. Floyd Reese: Former general manager of the Tennessee Titans for 13 years, Reese is now working in television. Pick a Super Bowl ad For the third year in a row, the NFL is asking fans to pick the pitch that will become its Super Bowl commercial. The winning pitch will inspire the NFL's commercial that will run during Super Bowl XLIII on Sunday, Feb. 1 on NBC. Group 2 (Bill Parcells model) If Parcells can leave coaching and still turn around the Miami Dolphins from the front office, then so can a number of former head coaches who have the experience to run a franchise. These three candidates could find the right coach to run the team in the same image and likeness they had when they coached, and all three have a solid working knowledge of personnel. Dan Reeves: Former head coach of the Denver Broncos, New York Giants and Atlanta Falcons. Marty Schottenheimer: Former head coach of the Cleveland Browns, Kansas City Chiefs, Washington Redskins and San Diego Chargers. Dick Vermeil: Former head coach of the Philadelphia Eagles, St. Louis Rams and Kansas City Chiefs. Group 3 (Jerry Angelo model) Stephan Savoia / Associated Press Expect to hear New England VP of player personnel Scott Pioli's name mentioned a lot in the offseason. This may be the strongest group, and it also would take some compensation to get these guys out of their present positions. If they don't have total control of the draft and the hiring and firing of the head coach, it's possible to get them. Any one of these five would be excellent to fix a franchise in need of leadership. New England's Scott Pioli is the hottest name in the league right now, and Pittsburgh's Kevin Colbert would be a steal if you could get him out of Pittsburgh. Kevin Colbert: Director of football operations for the Pittsburgh Steelers. Tom Heckert: General manager of the Philadelphia Eagles. Bill Kuharich: Vice president of player personnel for the Kansas City Chiefs. Randy Mueller: Senior executive for the San Diego Chargers. Scott Pioli: Vice president of player personnel for the New England Patriots. Group 4 (Thomas Dimitroff model) The people in this group are all from successful organizations and could impress an owner in an interview. They have been trained by high-profile executives and should carry the ability to bring the philosophy of a winning program to a new club. No one really knew Patriots personnel man Tom Dimitroff before his video interview with the Falcons last year, and now Atlanta has clinched a playoff spot, thanks largely to Dimitroff's first draft pick, Matt Ryan. Roll the dice and that could happen again this year with someone from this group. Mark Dominik: Director of pro personnel for the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. John Dorsey: Director of college scouting for the Green Bay Packers. Brian Gaine: Assistant director of player personnel for the Miami Dolphins. Ron Hughes: College scouting coordinator for the Pittsburgh Steelers. Scott Studwell: Director of college scouting for the Minnesota Vikings. Doug Whaley: Pro personnel coordinator for the Pittsburgh Steelers. By no means is this a list of the only 20 people capable of running an organization, but it's a good start when it comes to finding the right guy to run a club. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Gips Posted December 26, 2008 Report Share Posted December 26, 2008 Very nice piece of work you did here! The real question is how many of these mostly qualified prospects could be tricked...ah humm lured into coming to cleveland beyond a first meeting with randy"not so dandy"lerner...im betting 2 or 3 at best for a first meeting zero for a second...we end up keeping savage when randy not so dandy fails to convince anyone that his ask daddy first and wait a year for an answer structure is the only option....lol Mr. lerner is not so hands off as he puts on he puts his hands on in the worst possible way when it comes to any major decisions about almost anything that should be quickly handled by the head coach or the gm in full i suspect savage doesnt have the authority to fire coaches i think after savage done what a good gm does by getting rid of frye there was some new ground rules and agreements by commitee laid down that have led us where we are now... Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
YtownBrownsBacker Posted December 26, 2008 Report Share Posted December 26, 2008 Jerry Angelo, a Youngstown Chaney HS graduate and liflong Browns fan. He is not 100% satisfied with his duties and responsibilities in Chicago. Also underpaid as a GM in the NFL. With an additional title of VP and GM and say so in the draft, he could be lured away from Chicago. Mark Dominik has Jerry Angelo's old job at Tampa Bay and is ready to move on and up. Has had some clashes with Gruden. If Cleveland is planning on keeping Savage and reducing his role, Ron Hill would be an outstanding guy to have him report to. Pioli would be a perfect fit, he wouldn't demand total control over the roster makeup and draft. BTW, great job Bernie..............................................nice list. And since Lerner has curtailed Savage's out of town scouting trips, we may be looking at someone on that list. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Gips Posted December 26, 2008 Report Share Posted December 26, 2008 Jerry Angelo, a Youngstown Chaney HS graduate and liflong Browns fan. He is not 100% satisfied with his duties and responsibilities in Chicago. Also underpaid as a GM in the NFL. With an additional title of VP and GM and say so in the draft, he could be lured away from Chicago. Mark Dominik has Jerry Angelo's old job at Tampa Bay and is ready to move on and up. Has had some clashes with Gruden. If Cleveland is planning on keeping Savage and reducing his role, Ron Hill would be an outstanding guy to have him report to. Pioli would be a perfect fit, he wouldn't demand total control over the roster makeup and draft. BTW, great job Bernie..............................................nice list. And since Lerner has curtailed Savage's out of town scouting trips, we may be looking at someone on that list. Pioli is perfect but i doubt he will leave his current post i say keep away from the home state prospects we all love em but they are ussually not very gifted..the buckeye state doesnt produce front office football masterminds only mediocrity.. I think savage should go almost any of these guys would be able to jump into the job running as long as randy makes a sound decision and has a little trust by letting them do their thing unfettered but evaluated most of these guys are very seasoned unlike butch davis or savage and most will want and need certain powers..i think the coach should be hired by the gm and have a shared power of personnel because the coach if he is any good should know the type of players he needs to make his overall plan succeed.. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
BernietheKid Posted December 26, 2008 Author Report Share Posted December 26, 2008 Pioli is perfect but i doubt he will leave his current post i say keep away from the home state prospects we all love em but they are ussually not very gifted..the buckeye state doesnt produce football masterminds only mediocrity.. I think savage should go almost any of these guys would be able to jump into the job running as long as randy makes a sound decision and has a little trust by letting them do their thing unfettered but evaluated most of these guys are very seasoned unlike butch davis or savage and most will want and need certain powers..i think the coach should be hired by the gm and have a shared power of personnel because the coach if he is any good should know the type of players he needs to make his overall plan succeed.. I agree I don't think the GM should have the final say over the 53 man roster. I think it should be a combined group effort. That's the big problem here with Phil because he has the final word on it but that should be the coaches decision. You know the one calling the plays. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
YtownBrownsBacker Posted December 26, 2008 Report Share Posted December 26, 2008 I agree I don't think the GM should have the final say over the 53 man roster. I think it should be a combined group effort. That's the big problem here with Phil because he has the final word on it but that should be the coaches decision. You know the one calling the plays. I don't think the coach should be able to trump the GM either. A team effort with both agreeing should be the method desired. If that can't be accomplished there needs to be a deciding person. A person that the GM reports to on football matter. A President or Vice President of football operations. Let's have the whole front office buy in. No scape goats. We know Lerner doesn't know football and doesn't like to get involved, so there has to be someone to oversee the operation. It just can't be the GM as GOD. Actually, if Savage had a football person to report to and solve disputes between him and RAC, this whole mess might not have unraveled. Lerner is hands off and not a football person, the President is a finance and organization man, not a football person, Savage was a rookie GM with no guidence from above and RAc was a rookie HC. The operation was created to fail, no experience anywhere. If our next HC is a coordinator, then the GM must have experience and their should be a Director of football operations to oversee it all. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
ballpeen Posted December 27, 2008 Report Share Posted December 27, 2008 Just a FYI...for what it's worth...here is reports mortenson is saying Pioli is on the radar. http://www.brownsgab.com/2008/12/10/clayto...ible-gm-option/ Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.